19 Apr 2001
I recently emailed David Levy and begged him to ask Bruce Kimmel to recording the upcoming Dreamgirls concert. David replied that he thought Dreamgirls would benefit more from a John Yap-style note-for-note complete studio recording.
I’m going to have to disagree — we already have one studio recording of Dreamgirls, and as exciting as the material is, the album comes of as being a little lifeless. One only has to listen to a live performance of Jennifer Holiday ripping through And I Am Telling You I Am Not Going and you realize how much an audience feeds into the performance and helps her to blow the roof off the theatre. And who wouldn’t want to hear Lillias White, Audra McDonald, and Heather Headley chew their way through the score, with a sold-out audience cheering them on?
The real problem with the original Dreamgirls recording, I believe, is that it was recorded like a regular rock album, mixing together different instrumental and vocal takes (instead of recording live with the pit). Other albums recorded this way that come off sounding just as lifeless to me include Rent and Pippin. It wasn’t until I finally saw and heard Rent onstage live that I warmed up to the material.
Besides, John Yap has an incredible backlog of recordings he’s still mixing for release on Jay Records — it would take him years to get around to recording something like Dreamgirls. Some enterprising record company (if not Fynsworth Alley) needs to jump on this concert, because something like this only comes around for One Night Only.
I agree, agree, agree. But can anyone afford to record Audra AND Heather? Maybe if they donate it to charity….
Bill | 19 Apr 2001